Fed Decision, All Time Highs, and Earnings
Introduction
Over the past two years, we have gotten accustomed to short interest rate movements and inflation expectations, which often move together and are the primary drivers of stock, bond, and all other asset price movements. The mass market decline was driven by high inflation and massive interest rate increases. This decline was then stabilized by inflation cooling off and showing a trend back to normal.
However, the equity market has since rallied back to all-time highs regardless of interest rates remaining high. This proves that there is now a stronger force driving asset prices, particularly that of company ownership (i.e., equities).
On Wednesday, the Federal Reserve (the US central bank that determines short-term interest rates) announced that they would keep interest rates at the current level of between 5.25% and 5.50% and maintained its expectations of three cuts through the year to 4.50% to 4.75%. However, they also indicated that there would be expectations of fewer cuts in 2025 and 2026 than was previously forecasted. However, stock prices remain at all-time highs, which has been concerning for many investors.
So what is happening, and why are many investors confused about what drives equity prices? Lets deep dive into this.
Factors Affecting Equity Prices
When we buy any company(s), whether private or publicly listed, the primary motivator is buying earnings and companies' future earnings. A significant note is that corporate earnings are at their highest level in history, even in an environment where interest rates moved from 0% to north of 5% within a short period. Earnings have continued to rise with profit margin increases and revenue growth. The Fed also boosted its expectations for GDP growth, which indicates that the economy's production capacity is growing.
See the above chart, which shows forward expectations for increasing earnings.
Of course, company values will go up. They are making more money than they ever have, and there is an expectation that they will continue to grow at a fast pace.
When investing in bond markets, our expected return is the return we are contractually promised to receive throughout the lending agreement. With high interest rates, these are attractive.
However when investing in equities, our expected return is simply the earnings we are getting as owners of companies in addition to the earnings growth we receive over long durations. The earnings growth is a by-product of two key aspects:
- Growth in companies' ability to generate profit through lower operating costs and higher revenue generated from a larger economy.
- Inflation, as companies' costs go up, so do they increase their prices. That's how we as consumers experience inflation: by the cost of the goods and services these companies provide going up, so do their earnings.
See below a great chart showing the high correlation between earnings and stock prices, proving that earnings growth, which includes both factors mentioned above, is indeed the primary force of equity market growth.
Our view on equity prices is that they are natural to be at all-time highs, as earnings are also at all-time highs and should most usually be at all-time highs. The average listed company pays out less than 50% of its earnings in dividends. That means that companies are growing not only by the growth of their earnings but also by the earnings that are not distributed as dividends but instead retained in their value.
Conclusion
Be diversified, keep the focus on the long term, and cut out short-term noise, and you'll get a natural return based on the global production of goods and services we continue to need on a daily basis.
The Interactive Brokers logo is a registered trademark of Interactive Brokers LLC. ®